Esteemed blind musicians
I am a blind musicologist, music educator, and performer writing to you from Edinburgh. I am here as a guest of the University of Edinburgh to assess the challenges visually impaired musicians encounter when using Braille notation and audio technologies during their secondary and high school education, and to develop scientifically grounded solutions from the perspective of a blind expert.
The title of my research is: “Exploring the Functionalities of Braille and Audio Technologies in the Listening, Tactile Exploration, and Interpretation Practices of Visually Impaired Musicians: An Experimental Study.” This project is hosted by the Moray House School of Education and Sport at the University of Edinburgh and is supported by a nine-month scholarship from the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey.
The project is under the guidance of Prof. Dr. John Ravenscroft, whose expertise is invaluable to the development of the study.
I am reaching out to you through Elizabeth McCann, Teaching Fellow – Visual Impairment & VI CPD Coordinator at the Scottish Sensory Centre. Ethical approval for the project has been granted. Our aim is to reach blind and visually impaired students who are currently studying at the secondary school level in Scotland and have an interest in music, whether amateur or professional. We seek to assess their proficiency in using Braille notation and audio technologies, the challenges they face, the competence of their teachers in supporting them, and the current state of inclusive education for blind students in both mainstream and specialized schools.
The more blind and visually impaired young musicians we can engage with, the greater the success and impact of this project. However, I would like to clarify that our focus is specifically on the challenges that blind and visually impaired students encounter in participating in music education within general middle or high schools. More specifically, we aim to explore how a blind student in high school learns in music lessons with the aid of Braille notation and audio technologies, how they communicate what they have learned, what fundamental difficulties they face in learning musical instruments, whether there are specific issues that need to be discussed in relation to musical genres, what their needs are in gaining sufficient knowledge and experience in solfège, harmony, counterpoint, and choral studies, and what challenges they encounter in becoming successful musicians in stage performances.
To ensure that the project proceeds on a scientifically sound basis, we seek to engage with blind and visually impaired students aged 11-18, as well as their teachers and parents, through a series of academic activities, including surveys, in-depth interviews, and observations. Specifically, we wish to evaluate:
- The teacher’s sensitivity to the challenges faced by blind students and their problem-solving abilities;
- The student’s approach to using Braille and audio technologies, and the teacher’s guiding attitude in addressing these challenges.
Your insights, perspectives, and recommendations would be incredibly valuable to us as we move forward with this research. I am eager to meet with you and the blind and visually impaired musicians you may recommend, as well as their teachers and parents, in order to begin this important project.
Kind regards,
Assist Prof. Dr. Yusuf Dumlupınar
2219 International Postdoctoral Research Fellowship Programme for Turkish Citizens
RESEARCH PROPOSAL FORM
The proposal form should not exceed 5 (five) pages and expected to be prepared in Arial 11 font. Form must fill in taking into account the explanations given under each topic. Instructions, which colored in gray for the proposal form, should be deleted.
Name of the Researcher (Fellow): Yusuf Dumlupınar
Name of the Research: Exploring the Functionalities of Braille and Audio Technologies in the Listening, Tactile Exploration, and Interpretation Practices of Visually Impaired Musicians: An Experimental Study
Name of the Host: John Ravenscroft
Host Institution: The University of Edinburgh
Date: 22.07.2024
SUMMARY OF THE RESEARCH PLAN PROPOSAL
This research aims to evaluate the potential of Braille notation and audio technologies in facilitating the effective participation of visually impaired musicians in daily life activities. The primary objective is to examine in-depth the opportunities these technologies can provide in music education and to understand the challenges faced, particularly focusing on the roles of Braille notation and audio technologies in the learning processes.
It has been observed that Braille notation can slow down the learning process for some visually impaired musicians and may hinder active participation in mixed classroom environments. However, this notation is regarded as an indispensable part of the musical identity for blind and visually impaired musicians.
In this context, updating Braille notation to facilitate easier access to information and integrating it with new audio technologies is believed to make it a more effective and comprehensive tool in music education.
During the research process, both quantitative (surveys, tests) and qualitative (in-depth interviews, focus groups) data collection methods will be used to evaluate the daily life activities and learning processes of visually impaired musicians in a multifaceted manner. This data will be collected and analysed in collaboration with visually impaired students studying music at leading middle and high schools in the Scotland. The findings will provide a crucial foundation for assessing the effectiveness of current practices and developing innovative solutions in music education.
The results of the research could highlight the potential of Braille notation and audio technologies in supporting the musical abilities of visually impaired musicians, thereby having a profound impact on educational policies and practices. This study aims to make a significant contribution to the scientific literature by providing a resource for visually impaired individuals in the field of music education through an interdisciplinary approach.
Keywords: • Musical Experience • Visually Impaired Individuals • Braille Notation • Audio Technologies • Music Education